Head Strong: Did Hollywood inspire the meltdown men?
It's possible that Gordon Gekko, the villian in the movie "Wall Street," served as a role model for brokers out to make a killing.
By Michael Smerconish - Inquirer Inquirer Currents Columnist Forget Bernie Madoff.
The Wall Street veteran who might be the real scapegoat for our country's
financial meltdown hasn't closed a deal in more than two decades. Many presume
he spent at least some of that time in jail. But his influence has
stood the test of time. The prospect of duplicating his lifestyle and aura may
have drawn many young brokers to Wall Street - for better or worse. And now
he's coming back. Gordon Gekko. Sure, he's fictional.
But now that 20th Century Fox has confirmed that Oliver Stone will direct a
sequel to 1987's Wall Street and Michael Douglas will reprise his role
as its most ruthless corporate raider, it's worth considering Gekko's impact. The question: Is it
possible that young brokers were motivated by the Gekko blueprint, set out to
Wall Street to follow it, and in the process contributed to the breakdown of
our financial sector? After all, Stanley
Weiser, co-writer of the original movie, offered this last October: "...
what I find strange and oddly disturbing is that Gordon Gekko has been
mythologized and elevated from the role of villain to that of hero." Indeed, Gekko has
become a symbol of New York's financial sector - one so enduring that Douglas
himself told the New York Times in 2007 that he could do without "one more
drunken Wall Street broker" approaching him and saying, "You're the
man!" The original Wall
Street has grown into a work akin to the Godfather movies. Men everywhere
can still quote Gekko's most memorable lines: "Greed, for lack
of a better word, is good. Greed is right; greed works. Greed clarifies, cuts
through, and captures the essence of the evolutionary spirit." "If you're not
inside, you're outside." "What else you
got besides connections at the airport?" Last fall, as Douglas
participated in a United Nations panel on the nuclear test ban treaty,
reporters questioned him about the unfolding financial crisis. He was asked to
compare the threat of nuclear war with the "global Armageddon on Wall
Street." He tried, only to encounter this follow-up: "Are you saying,
Gordon, that greed is not good?" "I'm not saying
that," Douglas replied. "And my name is not Gordon. He's a character
I played 20 years ago." The exaltation comes
despite the movie's ending, with Gekko's protégé (played by Charlie Sheen),
seeking leniency after being arrested, turning over to the feds a taped
conversation in which Gekko seems to implicate himself in illegal maneuvering. So is Gordon Gekko the
muse behind the recklessness of some Wall Streeters? Stanley Fish,
professor of law at Florida International University and online contributor at
the New York Times, called the theory "entirely plausible," citing
the long history of people influenced by behavior they observe in works of
fiction. "It was reported
that a number of young men committed suicide after reading Goethe's The
Sorrows of Young Werther," he told me. "The undershirt industry
suffered a serious blow when Clark Gable didn't wear one in a popular movie.
Things might have gotten a bit better after Brando did A Streetcar Car Named
Desire wearing little else. Innumerable women tried to imitate the Audrey
Hepburn look - little black dress - after seeing her in Breakfast at
Tiffany's. I'm sure that motorcycles and motorcycling rose in popularity
after Easy Rider and The Wild One." On the other side of
the debate is Jim Rogers, the financial guru, co-founder (with George Soros) of
the Quantum Fund, author, and occasional professor at Columbia University.
Rogers called the theory a "stretch," arguing that real-life stock
market speculator Ivan Boesky (whose misdeeds ignited an insider-trading
scandal and drew a $100 million penalty in the late 1980s) and the man who
prosecuted him - then-U.S. Attorney Rudy Giuliani - probably made a more
lasting impression on Wall Street than Gekko. "Likewise,"
Rogers explained, "I do not think people who go to Wall Street need to
quote movies; they already have huge ambition to make money, or they would not
have gone there in the first place." He should know. Not
only did he make his fortune before he turned 40, but he made a bit
contribution to Stone's movie as well. A critical scene -
during which Sheen's character plots against Gekko with a rival trader - was
filmed in Rogers' house. At another point in the original script, Sheen's
character predicted that he'd celebrate his success with " . . . perhaps
something like he'd get a case of Dom," Rogers told me. Rogers, though, told
Stone about his plans to ride a motorcycle across China. Hence Sheen's
revelation to his love interest: "I think if I can make a bundle of cash
before I'm 30 and get out of this racket, I'll be able to ride my motorcycle
across China," he says. A clear case of art
imitating life. Left unresolved, however, is whether life has imitated Wall
Street. Contact Michael
Smerconish via www.mastalk.com.